Thursday, November 7, 2013

The Infinite Art Tournament, Left Bracket Third Round: Alma-Tadema v. Beckmann!

Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema has shown a lot of staying power in the Tournament.  After losing his opening match -- only the third in the whole dang show -- he has shown remarkable staying power in the left-hand bracket.  If other people are like me, that might have to do with us getting something of a taste for the pre-Rafaelites.  Or maybe not!  In any event, how is he going to do against Max Beckmann, who has had almost a year to rest up after his Third Round defeat?  Only one way to find out.  Ladies and Gentlemen, commence your voting.



Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema
1836 - 1912
Dutch; worked in England







Max Beckmann
1884 - 1950
German; worked in Netherlands and U.S.
  • Defeated Gentile Bellini in Round 1.
  • Edged out nineteenth century Frenchman Frederic Bazille in Round 2 by two votes -- YOUR VOTE COUNTS!
  • Knocked out by Jean-Michel Basquiat in Round 3.





----

Vote for the artist of your choice in the comments, or any other way that works for you. Commentary and links to additional work are welcome. Polls open for at least one month past posting.

14 comments:

Elizabeth said...

I didn't think I'd ever vote against Alma-Tadema, but I am. There's something very appealing about Beckmann's work this morning, an intensity that draws me more than the exquisite languor of pastel dreamscapes.

Christine M. said...

Beckmann

Morgan said...

I can't find anything bad to say about Beckmann, but I just cannot in good faith vote against Alma-Tadema in this matchup. There's something about these paintings that are just way compelling.

I vote for Alma-Tadema.

DrSchnell said...

Tough one! But I'll vote for Alma-Tadema

lamanyana said...

Beckmann

Ben said...

Sir Lawrence!

mrs.5000 said...

Almost a toss-up for me. I'll go with creepy Beckmann-world over sunny Alma-Tadema-world.

pfly said...

Beckmann! There's tons of curious mysterious iconographic symbolism in those triptychs, although apparently Beckmann denied it. We studied "Departure", the one with the king in a boat, in school. Sin and salvation? Response to Nazi Germany? Beckmann's own forced emigration? Beckmann denied it meant anything in particular. Hmm, okaaay.

pfly said...

PS, "Departure" is at the MoMA, if you are ever in NYC...

Chuckdaddy said...

Alma Tadema has grown on me, but not enough to beat the edgy flatness of Beckmann. By the way, Alma Tadema has a surprisingly interesting Wikipedia entry including childhood sickness, the gladiator, a rise fall rise, and a connection to candid camera

Michael5000 said...

Here's an email vote for Beckmann -- "Max is my man!"

Candida said...

Alma-Tadema.

Michael5000 said...

Oh hey look, I missed this one. Beckmann and Alma-Tadema have both grown on me a lot from low starting points. Alma-Tadema is fruitier than a box of tangerines, but I'm getting confident enough in my art history that I'm not so embarrassed by sentiment any more. Beckmann reminds me of a little bit of Tintin, except OMG WHAT IS CAPTAIN HADDOCK DOING TO THAT LADY?

Alma-Tadema.

Michael5000 said...

And time's up: Beckmann will advance to the Semi-Finals, and Alma-Tadema will have to feel pretty good about going 3-2-1 in a Tournament where most people hadn't heard of him coming in. The score was 7-5. Thanks for voting!